The Key Match Incident Review Panel has upheld all VAR interventions during the controversial 2-2 draw between Celtic and Aberdeen last week, including the disputed handball claim that occurred in the closing moments of the match.
During extra time, Alistair Johnston unleashed a powerful shot on goal, only to have it blocked by Aberdeen’s Duk in the final seconds. Celtic players vehemently argued for a penalty, believing Duk had handled the ball. However, after VAR review, the decision on the field stood, ultimately denying Celtic the opportunity for a penalty kick.
Despite speculation and suspicion from Celtic fans, no conclusive video evidence has emerged showing the ball making contact with Duk’s hand. The angles available suggest the ball may have hit his thigh, with some arm movement adding to the controversy.
Following a thorough review, the panel has backed referee Nick Walsh’s original call, deeming it to be accurate and well-supported. They stated, “The on-field decision was unanimous, with the referee in a suitable position to make the judgment. The Aberdeen defender did not use his arm to block the shot.”
With this confirmation from the panel, the decision remains unchanged, sparking ongoing debate among fans. This transparency and accountability in refereeing decisions have been a welcome change since Willie Collum became head of referees, with incident reports now being released on a weekly basis.
