At Elland Road, during the FA Cup clash between Leeds United and Harrogate Town, two former Leeds players raised concerns about a potential penalty that was not awarded to the underdog team in the first half. The incident involving Frenchman Josuha Guilavogui, who was making his first start for the Whites, occurred in the 12th minute when he appeared to bring down Harrogate’s Josh March. Referee James Bell, however, did not deem it a foul and instead awarded a free kick to Leeds. It is important to note that VAR was not in operation during this stage of the competition.
BBC pundit Stephen Warnock analyzed the situation and expressed his belief that March had indeed been fouled by Guilavogui, stating that the challenge was clumsy. Warnock raised questions about the referee’s decision making, suggesting that Harrogate was unlucky not to receive a penalty. Similarly, ex-Leeds goalkeeper Paul Robinson agreed with Warnock’s assessment, highlighting the contact between Guilavogui and March inside the box.
Despite the controversial non-call, Harrogate maintained a strong defensive performance, with Spanish Under-21 international Mateo Joseph coming close to scoring with a shot that hit the post in the 42nd minute. Robinson commended Harrogate for their defensive unity and resilience, noting their ability to anticipate danger, make crucial blocks, and execute timely tackles to keep Leeds at bay. In the end, even though they were denied a penalty, Harrogate’s determined effort was recognized by both former Leeds players.
