Celtic’s Striker Conundrum: Yamada or Strelec?
Celtic manager Brendan, Rodgers has made a solid start to the transfer window, signing several new players, including Benjamin Nygren and Kieran Tierney. However, the Hoops are still on the hunt for a marquee striker to guarantee goals. Two players are currently in the mix: Shin Yamada, a Japanese centre-forward from Kawasaki Frontale, and David Strelec, a Slovakian striker from Slovan Bratislava.
The Yamada Gamble
According to reports, Celtic have agreed a £1.5m deal with Kawasaki Frontale to sign Shin Yamada. However, the 25-year-old’s recent form has been underwhelming, with just two goals in 21 appearances this season. Despite his impressive form in 2024, Yamada’s struggles this year raise questions about his ability to make an immediate impact at Parkhead. Rodgers has emphasized the need for a striker who can “guarantee” goals, and Yamada’s inconsistency may make him a riskier signing.
The Strelec Option
David Strelec, on the other hand, has been a long-term target for Celtic. The 24-year-old Slovakian striker has a proven track record of scoring and creating goals, with 25 goals and eight assists in the 2024/25 campaign. Strelec’s experience in European football, including Champions League appearances, makes him an attractive option for Rodgers. His form suggests that he has the tools to hit the ground running in Glasgow and provide a big threat in front of goal for the Hoops.
Why Strelec is the Better Option
Given Rodgers’ desire for a marquee striker who can guarantee goals, Strelec seems like a more suitable option. While Yamada’s £1.5m price tag is attractive, Strelec’s potential to deliver results and develop over time makes him a more compelling signing. Strelec’s age, experience, and form make him a better fit for Celtic’s needs, and he could be a valuable addition to the squad.
The Potential for Growth
At 24, Strelec has room to develop and improve during his time at Celtic. With experience in European football and a proven track record of scoring goals, he has the potential to become a top-class striker. If Celtic are willing to invest £9m in the Slovakian striker, he could be a shrewd signing, providing a strong return on investment in the long term.
The Decision Ahead
Ultimately, the decision between Yamada and Strelec will depend on Rodgers’ vision for the team. If the manager is looking for a more immediate impact, Strelec’s form and experience make him the better option. However, if Celtic are willing to take a gamble on a younger player with potential, Yamada could still be a valuable signing. As the transfer window heats up, it will be interesting to see which striker Celtic ultimately choose to sign.
