The Prospect of Returns: Leicester Legends and Historical Precedents
The contracts of iconic figures Kasper Schmeichel, Jamie Vardy, and Kelechi Iheanacho are set to expire this summer, sparking rumors of a potential return to Leicester City. While the sentiment is high—especially for Vardy and Schmeichel—the club must weigh nostalgia against practical impact. Looking back at former teammate Andy King, a return doesn’t always provide the competitive balance a squad needs.
Currently, these veterans are scattered across Europe:
- Jamie Vardy: Embroiled in a Serie A relegation scrap with Cremonese.
- Kasper Schmeichel & Kelechi Iheanacho: Playing at Celtic under former Leicester boss Martin O’Neill.
- Daniel Amartey: Currently focused on regaining full match fitness.
Historical Precedents: Successes and Shortcomings
The concept of a “second act” at Leicester has a mixed track record. Very few players have successfully come full circle:
- Eddie Kelly: Initially signed in 1977, Kelly left and returned in 1981, eventually helping the club secure promotion under Gordon Milne.
- Kevin MacDonald: Sold to Liverpool in 1984 for £400,000, he returned briefly on loan in 1987 before eventually serving as a coach and interim manager in the early 90s.
- Peter Eastoe: Managed two brief loan spells in the early 80s, totaling 11 appearances and 2 goals.
Modern Returns
In the modern era, returns have been less frequent and often featured players past their prime:
- Steve Guppy: Returned in 2003 at age 34; he was a shadow of the player who had left four years prior.
- Paul Dickov: A more successful example, contributing to the League One title in 2008-09 with 21 appearances during his second stint.
Beyond the Pitch: Management and Coaching
Several former players have found their way back to the King Power in non-playing capacities. Current manager Gary Rowett and assistant Callum Davidson both played for the club. Conversely, Frank McLintock’s return as manager was “bittersweet,” as he oversaw a difficult transition that resulted in relegation.
Other former stars like Gerry Taggart, David Nish, and Craig Shakespeare also returned in coaching or administrative roles.
The Verdict: While the adage “never look back” persists in football, Leicester’s history shows that a return can work under the right circumstances. Whether Vardy or Schmeichel can add a successful final chapter remains a significant question for the upcoming window.
