Former Premier League referee has criticised officials for what he believes was a major error during clash between and .
Despite Leeds progressing to the semi-finals after a dramatic encounter at the London Stadium, Clattenburg insists the Whites were denied a “clear” penalty in the first half.
The controversial moment came when Maximilian Kilman challenged Anton Stach inside the box. The Leeds midfielder was caught heavily and forced off with injury, sparking immediate appeals from players and supporters. However, no penalty was awarded, and VAR upheld the on-field decision.
Clattenburg was unequivocal in his assessment.
“There is no doubt in my mind that Leeds United should have been awarded a penalty,” he said. “The challenge was reckless, there was contact on the player without touching the ball, and the ball was still in play.”
He also dismissed the VAR explanation that the incident was merely a coming together of players, arguing instead that it met the criteria for a foul and should have resulted in a spot-kick.
Fortunately for , the decision did not prove costly.
Goals from Ao Tanaka and had given them a strong position in the match, although late strikes from Mateus Fernandes and Axel Disasi dragged the contest into extra time and eventually penalties.
Leeds held their nerve in the shootout to secure progression, booking their place in the FA Cup semi-finals for the first time since 1987.
’s side will now face in the last four, with a place in the final at stake.
While the victory keeps Leeds’ cup dream alive, Clattenburg’s comments are likely to reignite debate around refereeing standards and VAR consistency—issues that continue to dominate the conversation in English football.
For Leeds, the focus now shifts to their semi-final showdown, but questions remain over how such a significant decision was missed on one of the game’s biggest stages.
