The Sunderland Spot-Kick Saga: Why Habib Diarra Took the Reigns Against Oxford
Following the infamous “Panenka-gate” incident where Enzo Le Fée’s casual effort was easily saved by Caoimhin Kelleher, Sunderland fans have been left wondering who would be trusted with the next penalty. On Sunday, during the FA Cup clash with Oxford United, that question was finally answered when Habib Diarra stepped up to secure a 1-0 victory and propel the Black Cats into the fifth round for the first time since 2015.
The shift in responsibility has sparked debate: is Diarra now the permanent designated taker, or has Le Fée been stripped of the role for good?
A Strategy of “Unpredictability”
Manager Regis Le Bris downplayed any talk of a rigid hierarchy or locker room tension. Instead, he described a fluid approach based on gut feeling and teammate synergy.
“We like to keep a bit of unpredictability!” Le Bris explained. “It was decided on the pitch. It is a question of confidence and who feels best placed to do it. Habib was very confident, and Enzo was comfortable with the decision.”
Keeping a Promise
The handover might not have been a punishment at all, but rather the fulfillment of a “gentleman’s agreement” made months ago. Back in August, Le Fée and Diarra had a similar on-field discussion. Le Fée took that penalty—and scored—but later admitted:
- The Deal: Le Fée promised that because Diarra let him take the first one, he would return the favor when the next opportunity arose.
- The Timing: Due to injuries and international breaks, Sunday was actually Diarra’s first chance to collect on that debt while both players were on the pitch together.
Collective Success Over Ego
While Le Bris admits the choice of taker isn’t set in stone, the successful strike against Oxford highlights a healthy dressing room culture. Rather than a battle of egos, the Sunderland squad appears to prioritize communication and “on-the-pitch” feel.
Having multiple confident options from twelve yards—and a group of players willing to share the spotlight—can only be seen as a massive plus as the club moves deeper into the competition.
